|
RELATIVE CARBON EMISSIONS - PLANES CARS and TRAINS
The table below shows the carbon emissions in tonnes per
person for a family of four and a couple taking two typical journeys into France
from the UK. Figures are from
www.co2balance.com, one of the few calculators that includes ferry travel.
|
|
CARBON EMISSIONS (TONNES) |
|
Plane |
Car and
ferry |
Train |
|
Per person |
Per person 2
in car |
Per person 4
in car |
Per person |
|
London to Reims |
0.12 |
0.08 |
0.05 |
0.04 |
|
London to Bordeaux |
0.24 |
0.16 |
0.09 |
0.08 |
The number of travellers in the party makes little
difference to the emissions per person when flying or going by train, but there
is a significant difference between 2 or 4 people in the car. This of course is
because one person more or less has little effect in a plane or train, but has a
major impact in the car.
The London to Paris car journey included a Dover Calais
return ferry crossing, and the Bordeaux trip a ferry from Portsmouth to Caen.
The figures for the car are based on a family saloon of about 1.8 litres.
The impact of 4 people flying is two and a half times
greater than travelling by car, and one and half times greater for 2 people. The
train was less environmentally damaging than the car, but not by much. For a
family of four, rail travel will certainly be the most expensive option, and
often presents obstacles in terms of practicalities.
Significantly, most carbon calculators, including the one
we used, only allow for the damage caused by Co2 emissions, whereas the
pollution and contrails produced by jet planes actually have a climate impact
reckoned to be nearly three times greater than that of the CO2 in the fuel they
burn (see
www.grida.no/climate/ipcc/aviation/).
A comparison of online carbon calculators carried out by
COIN (Climate Outreach and Information Network), also found that many of the
carbon offsetting websites produced lower than average estimates of the carbon
emissions produced by flying. (See
http://coinet.org.uk/solutions/carboncalculations).
This is a worrying trend, as these are precisely the sites
used by those who wish to continue flying, but to do something about the
environmental effects by offsetting.
Drive-Alive say it is simple: never mind the offsetting,
try real carbon reduction! Take advantage of the flexibility of a driving
holiday. Go where you want, when you want and take what you want with you. Relax
on the ferry instead of submitting yourself to the traumas of delayed flights to
inconvenient airports at uncivilised hours.
Experience the open roads of France where you are in
control, and enjoy the satisfaction of knowing that, although no carbon-based
transport is environmentally friendly, at least driving is considerably less
damaging than flying.
Or use the really environmentally friendly train. Take the
high speed Eurostar passenger train and be whisked in comfort from the spanking
new terminal at London St Pancras (From Nov 14th) and arrive in Paris in just 2
hour 15 minutes. The service also goes to Brussels in 1 hour 51 minutes and
Lille in only 1 hour 20 minutes. And you can of course connect with the European
train network for a guilt-free and stress-free holiday.
Plan your complete driving holiday online at
www.drive-alive.co.uk.
Return to information about driving
in Europe.
|
